Who Keeps the Bling After a Break-up? Engagement ring ownership is defined under Ohio law.
At 18 years old, Johnny and Patty are in love. Johnny has been dating Patty for almost 4 years. Upon graduating high school, both decide to attend a four-year college in Dayton, Ohio. Johnny and Patty decide to take all the same classes and spend nearly every waking minute with each other. The summer prior to moving, Johnny approaches Patty’s parents and asks if he can propose. Patty’s parents grant permission, believing the two to be inseparable. Johnny, who recently fell into some money from an inheritance, decides to purchase a $25,000 dollar, (3-carat) solitaire ring. He absolutely loves the ring, and upon asking Patty to marry him, she immediately accepts. Three weeks into the engagement, Patty and Johnny have a severe argument about their hometown sports team and, believing their differences to be too severe, decide to call off the engagement. Patty tells Johnny she doesn’t plan on returning the engagement ring and is hoping to sell the ring and pay for a semester of college tuition. Johnny runs home and … Read More... “Engagement Ring Blues”